← Blog
Q&ANovember 22, 20267 min read

Stonehenge's Missing Journey

Dr. Anthony Clarke explains the mineral evidence behind a proposed Scottish origin for the Altar Stone, and the questions still surrounding its journey.

Stonehenge's Missing Journey
garethwiscombe, CC BY 2.0

Stonehenge took shape over centuries on Salisbury Plain in southern England. Its stones arrived from different landscapes. The large sarsens have been traced to a source much closer to the monument, while some of the smaller bluestones came from west Wales. The sandstone Altar Stone at its center, weighing 6 metric tons, presented a separate problem.

In 2024, a team led by Anthony Clarke compared the ages and chemistry of tiny minerals within the Altar Stone with rocks across Britain and Ireland. Their study, published in Nature, inferred an origin in the Orcadian Basin of northeast Scotland. A stone long associated with Wales now pointed much farther north.

Its precise source and transport route remain unknown. In a written interview in October 2026, we asked Dr. Clarke about the geological evidence and what it might reveal about the people who brought the stone to Stonehenge.

Since the interview, a November 2026 study led by Duncan Pirrie has added important constraints. It supports the earlier evidence for a Laurentian source of the stone's heavy minerals, but finds that many examined Orcadian Basin outcrops do not match its full characteristics. No examined UK Old Red Sandstone outcrop matches the complete geological profile. The exact source remains unresolved, including whether a Scottish outcrop not yet matched could provide an answer.

Dr. Anthony Clarke beside the stones at Stonehenge in 2024

Photo: Curtin University

Dr. Anthony Clarke at Stonehenge in 2024.

Dr. Anthony Clarke

Dr. Anthony Clarke is a research fellow at Curtin University, working in its School of Earth and Planetary Sciences and Timescales of Mineral Systems Group. He led the 2024 Nature study of the Altar Stone's proposed Scottish provenance and subsequent research examining the geological evidence for glacial transport. His work uses the ages and chemistry of minerals to investigate where rocks and sediments originated.

Reading the mineral record

Strange Route · Your 2024 study traced the Altar Stone to northeast Scotland using tiny mineral grains. What did you need to check before you felt confident that it had come from so far away?

Dr. Anthony Clarke

We needed to be confident that the geological fingerprint wasn't just a coincidence. We analysed the ages and chemistry of different minerals within the Altar Stone: zircon, apatite and rutile. Since the Altar Stone is a sedimentary rock, these tiny crystals preserve information about the geological history of the rocks from which they originated.

We then compared these "fingerprints" with rocks across Britain and Ireland. The results were remarkably consistent with the Old Red Sandstone of northeast Scotland's Orcadian Basin, but quite different from rocks in Wales, where the Altar Stone was previously thought to have originated.

Like a forensic investigation, several lines of evidence pointed towards the same region, giving us confidence in our interpretation.

Historical view of Stonehenge with the low Altar Stone beneath fallen stones

Photo: Col. Sir Henry James / The J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles (CC0)

The Altar Stone is the low horizontal slab beneath the larger fallen stones in this 1867 view.

Testing the ice theory

A mineral grain can survive more than one journey. That makes a northern geological signature in a southern river more complicated than it first appears. Clarke's river-sand research, published in 2026, examined whether the sediments near Stonehenge preserved evidence of glacial delivery.

Strange Route · In your recent study of river sand near Stonehenge, some grains had clues linking them to northern Britain, but you concluded they hadn't been brought there by glaciers. How did you work out the difference?

Dr. Anthony Clarke

Finding minerals with a northern British fingerprint in southern England doesn't necessarily mean glaciers transported them there. Minerals such as zircon are incredibly durable and can survive multiple cycles of erosion, transport and deposition over hundreds of millions of years.

We compared the ages of zircon grains in rivers around Stonehenge with those from older sedimentary rocks across Britain. They closely matched sediments from the nearby London Basin, suggesting the grains had been recycled from rocks that once covered Salisbury Plain. This is a geological process called "mass wasting".

Importantly, we also found no convincing geological fingerprint of glacial transport. The evidence favours sediment recycling rather than glaciers delivering material directly to Stonehenge.

The route still missing

The transport research also includes ice-sheet modeling. Assuming a Scottish source, it allows the possibility that ice moved rocks partway south, while leaving a substantial journey that people would still have had to make. This does not establish the Altar Stone's source or exact route.

Strange Route · Taking your recent studies together, how much can we now say about the Altar Stone's journey, and which parts are still a mystery?

Dr. Anthony Clarke

I'm increasingly confident that the Altar Stone originated in northeast Scotland, more than 700 kilometres from Stonehenge. Our latest work suggests that mainland Scotland, particularly the Caithness region, is a promising source.

We can also say that glaciers are unlikely to have delivered the stone directly to Stonehenge. Our modelling suggests ice could potentially have transported Scottish rocks partway south to a now-submerged area in the North Sea called Doggerbank, but this would still have required substantial human involvement.

What remains unknown is the precise source location, the route taken and how the stone was transported. In my opinion, a journey involving boats seems plausible, but we cannot yet demonstrate that this is what happened.

Dr. Anthony Clarke at Stonehenge in 2023

Photo: Curtin University

Dr. Anthony Clarke at Stonehenge in 2023.

One undertaking or several moves

Strange Route · When people began moving the stone, can the evidence tell us whether it was one big undertaking or a series of moves, perhaps over generations?

Dr. Anthony Clarke

Unfortunately, geological evidence cannot tell us how long the journey took or whether it happened in stages.

I think it's entirely possible that the stone was moved between communities, perhaps spending time at other locations before eventually reaching Stonehenge. Equally, it could have been transported as part of a single coordinated undertaking.

Stonehenge itself developed over many centuries, so we know its construction was not a single event. However, we currently have no direct evidence establishing whether the Altar Stone's journey was equally prolonged.

Why this stone

Strange Route · If you could ask the people who brought the Altar Stone to Stonehenge one question, what would you most want to know?

Dr. Anthony Clarke

I'd want to ask them why they went to such extraordinary lengths to bring this particular stone to Stonehenge.

We can investigate where the stone originated and explore how it might have been transported, but understanding why people undertook such an extraordinary journey may be something we never know.

Was the stone spiritually significant? Did it represent connections between distant communities, or perhaps commemorate an important event?

For me, the human motivation behind moving a six-tonne stone across Britain is the most fascinating part of the mystery.

Looking beyond Stonehenge

Strange Route · What would we need to find to get a clearer answer about how the stone reached Stonehenge?

Dr. Anthony Clarke

I think one of the most promising avenues is to look beyond Stonehenge itself. Investigating other Neolithic monuments and archaeological sites across Britain could reveal important connections between distant communities and help us understand how stones, people and ideas moved across the landscape.

By examining the geological origins of stones at other monuments, we might identify patterns of movement or connections that have previously gone unnoticed.

The people behind the journey

Dr. Clarke’s suggestion to look at other monuments expands the investigation beyond one stone. Their geological origins may preserve evidence of connections between distant communities. Finding those patterns could help explain how people and materials moved across Britain, even if the reasons for a particular journey remain harder to recover. We would still want to ask the same question Dr. Clarke chose: what made this particular stone worth bringing to Stonehenge? Hopefully, future research by Dr. Clarke and his team will bring us closer to understanding that choice.

Sources

  • Written interview with Dr. Anthony Clarke in October 2026.

Photo credits

Both photographs of Dr. Clarke: Curtin University.

Stonehenge: Centre Trilithon (A) and Altar Stone, 1867. Col. Sir Henry James. The J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles, 84.XB.763.13.1. Digital image courtesy of Getty’s Open Content Program (CC0).

Featured Places

Mark this dispatch

Comments

0 on the record

  • No comments yet. Be the first witness.